2.
An Update on Our Changing Real Estate
Agency Rules About
a seven weeks ago I wrote an article
titled, "The Rules They Are a
Changing." In the article I
discussed how we as an industry need to
change our rules to reflect how to
handle properties that are offered in
the marketplace with discounted commission
rates.
Well,
I don't think I've ever received so many
E-mails from agents thanking me for
openly addressing a subject that has
been on so many people's minds these
days, while at the same time not being
adequately addressed by our industry.
One
of the E-mails came from Hank
Sorensen, a Florida attorney
specializing in representing brokers,
agents, and their clients through his
company, Brokers
Legal Group. And Hank had some very
interesting developments that he told me about regarding real estate
agency relationships and the current
laws of the land...
In
Florida, for example, Hank tells me that
"Under Florida law, every agent is
now assumed to be operating in a
transactional agency status, which
expressly disclaims any fiduciary
responsibility to the client (versus
single agency, which does attach a
fiduciary status), and I see no reason
for an agent to ever show a low co-op
fee listing in Florida if they don’t
want to."
In
following up with Hank, he further told
me that "Transactional agency is
akin to dual agency, except that in the
latter, the brokerage/agent represents
both parties, and in a transactional
status, they represent the
"transaction," and not any
party specifically. In Florida, an
agent is presumed to be operating in a
transactional status unless proper
documents are signed making the
brokerage/agent a single agent, in which
a fiduciary duty attaches. In a
transactional status, any fiduciary
duties are expressly disclaimed."
In
addition, Hank sent me information about
a court case in Iowa, Next Generation
Realty, Inc. et al v. Iowa Realty, Inc.
et al. The court decision in this
case was rendered on February 18, 2003.
In
this case the court declared that the
"unilateral offering of
compensation by listing firms to other
participants hardly constitutes price-
fixing, as the exchange of this
information is obviously necessary so
that the potential selling realtor
can decide whether it is economically
worth its effort to attempt sale of the
property."
In
his cover letter to me along with the
information he sent me about this case,
Hank further stated "Obviously no
business should be required to represent
clients at a loss, and having brokerages
continue to work for ever-decreasing
commission schedules will cause, at some
point, a loss to be sustained by the
brokerage and/or agent because of the
reduced commission schedule. Therefore,
it is up to the individual brokerage or
agent to determine when they are
potentially going to cross this line,
which will result in the agent not
showing a specific property solely due
to the cooperating compensation offered
in the MLS."
Now
obviously this case was decided in Iowa,
and Hank practices law in Florida. In
addition, Hank points out that because
the decision in the Iowa case was
neither published or appealed, it will
have very limited value as a
precedential case in the state of Iowa.
And outside of Iowa, Hank says it will
only have what he refers to as
"persuasive authority" in any
other state.
Knowing
that the laws will vary depending on
where you're
currently working as a real estate
agent, it's important that you know what
the laws are are when it comes to your
obligations in representing your clients
and prospects. So make sure that you
know what the laws are in your area, and
also make sure that you're constantly
working within them, too.
But
still
it's nice to know that a court in
the state of Iowa understands what we're
up against today as real estate agents
doing business in a world of discounted
commissions, and that we shouldn't be
obligated to work on transactions that
could potentially hurt our success as
businesspeople.
Click
here if you'd like more information
on my one-on-one coaching program to
take your real estate productivity to
the next level. One-on-one coaching is
available for both real estate agents
and company management.
"After 20 years in real estate I needed to revive my business and look at new options and ideas. Together Jim and I evaluated my entire business plan, designed new strategies, and implemented a game plan that's now making more money for both me and my team."
Bill Ukropina
CB Richard Ellis
Click
Here for More Testimonials
|